Inpatient Mental Health Must Be Abolished: 3 Unnecessary Incarceration of the Mentally Ill
Table of Contents
Mental health has always been a sensitive issue. The mainstream approach to treating it has been inpatient mental health care. However, this practice has proven to be nothing but a prison sentence for those who are suffering from mental illnesses. Inpatient mental health is not only ineffective but is also dangerous. We need to abolish it in order to provide better care for the mentally ill.
Inpatient mental health care has been the primary method of treating the mentally ill for many years. Patients are institutionalized and their movements are restricted, leading to a sense of hopelessness and anxiety that can worsen their mental health. The treatment methods used in these facilities are often ineffective and can even cause harm to the patients.
There is a better way to care for the mentally ill. We need to move away from inpatient mental health care and explore alternative options that provide better care and support for patients. In this article, we will explore the dark side of inpatient mental health care and provide evidence supporting our contrarian viewpoint that it must be abolished. We will also address common counterarguments that may be made against our viewpoint.
The Dark Side of Inpatient Mental Health Care.
Inpatient mental health care has long been an accepted method for treating the mentally ill. However, it is not as safe and secure as it may seem. In reality, it is more like a prison for those who are suffering from mental illnesses. Patients are locked up in wards, and their movements are restricted. The constant surveillance and the confinement can cause patients to feel more anxious and paranoid, leading to a worsening of their condition.
Patients in these facilities are often subjected to harsh and dehumanizing treatment methods. These can include forced medication, isolation, and even physical restraints. The use of such methods can cause long-lasting psychological trauma to patients, and can even result in a deterioration of their mental health.
Counterargument: While it is true that patients in inpatient mental health care are confined, it is important to note that this is for their own safety. Patients who are in the midst of a mental health crisis may harm themselves or others, and the confinement is necessary to prevent this from happening.
Response: There are alternative options available that are just as effective in preventing harm to patients without confining them to a mental health facility. For example, outpatient care and community-based care provide patients with the support they need without resorting to confinement.
The Problem with Medication
Psychotropic drugs are often used as a quick fix solution to manage patients’ mental illnesses. Unfortunately, the side effects of these medications are often ignored. These drugs have been known to cause severe side effects such as weight gain, lethargy, and sexual dysfunction. Furthermore, they can lead to long-term health problems such as liver and kidney damage.
Many patients in inpatient mental health care are prescribed high doses of these medications, leading to a loss of autonomy and even dependency. Patients may develop a tolerance for the drugs, leading to an increased dosage and an eventual dependency that can be difficult to break.
Counterargument: Medication is necessary to treat mental illnesses, and inpatient mental health care is the best option for providing patients with the medication they need.
Response: Medication is just one part of mental health care. There are alternative options available that do not rely solely on medication. For example, therapy and other forms of talk therapy have been shown to be just as effective in treating mental illness as medication.
The Importance of Personal Freedom
The freedom to live life on one’s own terms is a basic human right. Inpatient mental health care deprives patients of this right. Patients
are stripped of their autonomy and are forced to live in a highly regulated environment where every aspect of their life is controlled by the facility. Patients are unable to make decisions for themselves, and their freedom of movement is severely restricted.
In addition, patients in inpatient mental health care are often stigmatized and discriminated against, which can further damage their mental health. Patients may feel trapped and powerless, leading to a sense of hopelessness and a worsening of their condition.
Counterargument: The highly regulated environment of inpatient mental health care is necessary to provide patients with the structure and support they need to recover from their mental illness.
Response: While structure and support are important, it is possible to provide this without depriving patients of their personal freedom. Community-based care and outpatient care provide patients with the support they need while allowing them to live their lives on their own terms.
The Failure of Inpatient Mental Health Care to Address Root Causes
Inpatient mental health care is often focused on managing symptoms rather than addressing the root causes of mental illness. This can lead to a cycle of repeated hospitalizations as patients fail to make progress in addressing the underlying issues causing their mental illness.
In addition, inpatient mental health care often fails to address the social and environmental factors that contribute to mental illness. These factors can include poverty, homelessness, and social isolation. Inpatient mental health care is not equipped to address these issues, and patients may return to the same environment that contributed to their mental illness in the first place.
Counterargument: Inpatient mental health care is designed to address symptoms and provide a safe environment for patients to recover.
Response: While providing a safe environment is important, it is not enough to truly address mental illness. Community-based care and outpatient care are better equipped to address the root causes of mental illness by providing patients with the resources and support they need to make lasting changes in their lives.
The High Cost of Inpatient Mental Health Care
Inpatient mental health care is an incredibly expensive method of treating mental illness. The cost of hospitalization, medication, and other treatments can add up quickly, leaving patients and their families with a significant financial burden.
In addition, inpatient mental health care often fails to address the underlying issues that contribute to mental illness. This can result in repeated hospitalizations, further increasing the cost of care.
Counterargument: Inpatient mental health care is necessary to provide patients with the care they need, regardless of the cost.
Response: While it is true that patients need care, inpatient mental health care is not the only option. Community-based care and outpatient care are more cost-effective and provide better long-term outcomes for patients.
The Need for Systemic Change
The issues with inpatient mental health care are not isolated incidents. They are a result of a larger systemic problem in how we approach mental health care. We need to move away from the institutionalization of the mentally ill and towards a community-based approach that provides patients with the support and resources they need to recover.
Counterargument: Systemic change is difficult to achieve, and inpatient mental health care is the best option we have at the moment.
Response: While systemic change is difficult, it is not impossible. By investing in community-based care and outpatient care, we can provide patients with the care they need while moving away from the harmful and ineffective practice of inpatient mental health care.
Inpatient mental health care is a harmful and ineffective method of treating mental illness. Patients are stripped of their personal freedom, subjected to dehumanizing treatment methods, and fail to receive the care they need to truly recover. We need to move away from this practice and explore alternative options that provide better care and support for the mentally ill. By investing in community-based care
“Systemic issues such as funding and stigma play a major role in perpetuating the use of inpatient care, despite its many flaws”
What is inpatient mental health care?
Inpatient mental health care is a type of treatment that involves admitting patients to a hospital or other facility for 24-hour care and monitoring. This type of care is typically reserved for patients who are experiencing severe symptoms or who are at risk of harming themselves or others.
How long do patients typically stay in inpatient mental health care?
The length of stay in inpatient mental health care can vary depending on the patient’s needs and the severity of their condition. Some patients may only stay for a few days or weeks, while others may stay for several months.
What types of treatment are offered in inpatient mental health care?
Inpatient mental health care may include a range of treatments, such as medication management, individual and group therapy, behavioral therapy, and other types of support and counseling.
How effective is inpatient mental health care?
The effectiveness of inpatient mental health care can vary depending on the patient’s individual needs and circumstances. While some patients may benefit greatly from inpatient care, others may not respond as well to this type of treatment.
What are the alternatives to inpatient mental health care?
Community-based care and outpatient care are two common alternatives to inpatient mental health care. These types of care allow patients to receive treatment while still maintaining their personal freedom and independence. Additionally, there are many alternative therapies and treatments that may be effective for some patients.