The traditional marketing funnel is dead. Discover the 4S behaviors—Seeking, Screening, Selecting, and Sharing—and learn how this new framework is the key to winning in the chaotic, non-linear modern customer journey.
The Obsolete Funnel: How 4S Behaviors Are Redefining the Modern Consumer Journey
Stop thinking in straight lines. The consumer journey is no longer a predictable funnel; it's a chaotic, cyclical ecosystem of discovery and decision. It's time to discard the old maps and embrace the four foundational behaviors that truly drive growth today: Seeking, Screening, Selecting, and Sharing.
The Great Unraveling: Why the Traditional Marketing Funnel is Broken
For decades, we clung to the comforting linearity of the marketing funnel. Awareness, Interest, Desire, Action. It was simple, measurable, and wrong. Today's consumer, armed with infinite information and endless choice, doesn't walk a straight path. They leap, backtrack, and spiral through what Google aptly calls the "messy middle".
From Linear Paths to Chaotic Loops
The empowered consumer is in a constant state of exploration and evaluation, simultaneously gathering information and filtering options. This shift from a marketer-defined path to a consumer-driven loop renders the old funnel obsolete. It’s no longer about pushing people down; it’s about being the most relevant answer wherever they are in their chaotic journey.
Hover Over a Behavior
Explore the core principles of the 4S framework.
Introducing the 4S Framework: A New Compass for a New Landscape
To navigate this new reality, we need a new model. Not another rigid funnel, but a flexible framework that describes observable behaviors. The 4S framework provides this compass. It’s built on four interconnected, cyclical actions that define the modern consumer journey.
Not a Funnel, but a Flywheel
Unlike a funnel that terminates at purchase, the 4S model acts as a flywheel. The final stage, 'Sharing', directly fuels the 'Seeking' and 'Screening' stages for future customers, creating a self-perpetuating cycle of growth. Understanding how to influence each of these behaviors is the new imperative for marketers.
DEEP DIVE: The 'Seeking' Phase - Mastering the Art of Discovery
Seeking is the active hunt for information, solutions, or inspiration. It's more than just keywords in a search bar; it's about understanding the underlying intent behind every query, whether it's typed, spoken, or visual. In an age of information overload, your brand must become the clearest signal in the noise.
Content Strategies for the Seeking Mindset
To win the Seeking phase, you need to think like a publisher. Move away from disjointed blog posts towards comprehensive pillar pages and topic clusters. This strategy not only satisfies user intent more effectively but also signals your authority to search engines, making you the definitive answer for your domain.
Content Strategy Calculator
Generate ideas for a Pillar Page and its supporting Cluster Content.
Interactive Trust Signal Library
Customer Reviews
UGC Photos
Expert Endorsements
Case Studies
Testimonials
Industry Awards
"As Seen On" Logos
Security Badges
DEEP DIVE: The 'Screening' Phase - Winning the Battle of the Shortlist
Screening is the rapid, often subconscious, process of filtering options. As consumers are inundated with choices, they rely on mental shortcuts and trust signals to decide what deserves their attention. This is where your brand's credibility is tested in milliseconds. Failing the screening test means you're not even in the running.
Signals of Trust: The New Currency
Your value proposition must be instantly clear, but that's not enough. You must surround it with undeniable signals of trust. As the Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman's work on cognitive biases shows, people often make decisions based on heuristics, not deep analysis. Social proof, expert authority, and transparent data are the most potent tools to win this phase. For an in-depth look at this, the Nielsen Norman Group offers fantastic insights into social proof's power.
DEEP DIVE: The 'Selecting' Phase - Engineering the Moment of Choice
Selecting is the final step before conversion. The consumer has sought out information, screened their options, and now they are ready to choose. At this critical juncture, your job is to eliminate all friction and amplify confidence. Any hesitation, confusion, or obstacle can send them right back to the 'Screening' phase with your competitor.
Reducing Friction, Maximizing Confidence
The perfect selection experience is seamless and reassuring. This means clear pricing, simple navigation, personalized offers, and readily available support. Every element, from your call-to-action button to your checkout process, must be optimized to make the decision to choose you the easiest and most logical one.
Website Friction Audit
Check the boxes for any friction points present on your site to calculate a 'Friction Score'.
DEEP DIVE: The 'Sharing' Phase - Fueling the Flywheel of Advocacy
Sharing is the most potent and often neglected phase. It’s where a single transaction transforms into a lasting relationship and a powerful marketing asset. When a customer shares their positive experience, they are not just providing a testimonial; they are initiating the 'Seeking' and 'Screening' journeys for their entire network.
Turning Customers into Marketers
To encourage sharing, you must create experiences worth talking about. This goes beyond a good product. It includes exceptional customer service, delightful unboxing experiences, and building a community your customers are proud to be a part of. Actively fostering user-generated content (UGC) and referral programs isn't a "nice-to-have"; it's the engine of the 4S flywheel.
The 4S Tech Stack: Architecting for the New Reality
Supporting a 4S-centric strategy requires a modern, integrated technology stack. Siloed data and disconnected tools are the enemies of a seamless journey. The goal is to build a unified view of the customer so you can understand and respond to their behavior in real-time, no matter which 'S' they're currently in.
The Data Foundation
A Customer Data Platform (CDP) is the heart of a modern stack. It unifies data from all touchpoints—website, app, CRM, support—to create a single, persistent customer profile. This foundation allows your engagement and analytics tools to work from a single source of truth, enabling true personalization at scale.
This would be an interactive "build your stack" component.
Imagine dragging & dropping icons for CDPs, CRMs, Analytics, etc., onto a canvas to visualize a connected, 4S-centric tech stack.
Organizational Shift: Rebuilding Your Team Around the Journey
Technology and strategy are only part of the equation. To truly embrace the 4S framework, you must break down the organizational silos that mirror the old, linear funnel. A "Paid Media Team" and a "Content Team" that don't collaborate are fundamentally unequipped to manage a cyclical, multi-touchpoint journey.
From Channel-Focused to Journey-Focused Teams
The future belongs to cross-functional "pods" or squads organized around stages of the customer journey, not marketing channels. A "Discovery Pod" might include specialists in SEO, content, and PR, all working towards the shared goal of winning the 'Seeking' and 'Screening' phases. This structure fosters collaboration and a holistic understanding of the customer's experience.
The Future of the 4S: AI, Immersive Experiences, and Predictive Journeys
The 4S behaviors are not static. Emerging technologies will continue to shape them in profound ways.
AI as a 4S Co-pilot
Artificial intelligence will move from a tool for optimization to a co-pilot for the entire journey. It will predict a user's 'Seeking' intent before they type, dynamically generate content to win the 'Screening' phase, and personalize the 'Selecting' offer to an individual level, all in real-time.
Your 4S Action Plan: A Strategic Blueprint for Implementation
Shifting to a 4S-centric model is a journey, not an overnight change. Here is a practical, three-phase blueprint to guide your transition from a linear funnel mindset to a dynamic flywheel strategy.
Phase 1: Audit & Map
You can't optimize a journey you don't understand. Begin by mapping your current customer journeys using analytics, user interviews, and heatmaps. Identify the key touchpoints where Seeking, Screening, Selecting, and Sharing occur. Where are the drop-off points? Where are the moments of delight?
Phase 2: Strategize & Prioritize
With your map in hand, identify the biggest opportunities. Is your 'Screening' phase weak due to a lack of social proof? Is your 'Selecting' process full of friction? Prioritize one or two key areas to focus on first. Develop specific strategies for each 'S', such as creating a new testimonial campaign ('Screening') or launching a referral program ('Sharing').
Phase 3: Execute, Measure & Iterate
Launch pilot programs based on your prioritized strategies. Crucially, adapt your measurement framework. Move beyond last-click attribution and adopt metrics that reflect the health of each 'S' stage. Measure, learn, and continuously iterate. The 4S journey is a loop, and so is the process of optimizing for it.
Frequently Asked Questions
The key difference is linearity vs. cyclicality. Traditional funnels like AIDA (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action) are linear, assuming a predictable, one-way path to purchase. The 4S model is a cyclical, non-linear framework that reflects the modern 'messy middle' where consumers loop between Seeking, Screening, Selecting, and Sharing in any order, driven by context and information needs. It's a flywheel, not a funnel, where each stage can feed the others, especially the 'Sharing' phase which directly fuels 'Seeking' and 'Screening' for new prospects.
Absolutely. While the touchpoints may differ, the underlying human behaviors are the same. A B2B buyer is still 'Seeking' solutions through industry reports and vendor websites, 'Screening' options via case studies and peer reviews on G2 or Capterra, 'Selecting' based on demos and ROI calculators, and 'Sharing' their experience in testimonials or industry forums. The buying committee adds complexity, but each member undergoes their own micro 4S journey.
It's context-dependent, but for most businesses, the highest-leverage starting point is 'Screening'. This is where trust is won or lost. You can have the best discovery ('Seeking') and the smoothest checkout ('Selecting'), but if you fail the screening test—poor reviews, unclear value proposition, no social proof—you'll be eliminated from consideration instantly. Nailing your trust signals provides the foundation upon which the other 'S' strategies can be built.
Measurement must shift from last-touch attribution to a more holistic view. Use a combination of metrics mapped to each 'S': For 'Seeking', track organic visibility, share of voice, and branded search volume. For 'Screening', monitor review scores, on-site engagement with trust signals (like case study downloads), and bounce rates on key pages. For 'Selecting', focus on conversion rates, cart abandonment, and lead-to-close time. For 'Sharing', measure Net Promoter Score (NPS), user-generated content volume, and referral traffic. A unified data platform (like a CDP) is essential to connect these dots into a coherent journey view.
While '4S' is a framework for understanding existing behavior, many successful modern brands intuitively operate this way. Think of Amazon: It excels at 'Seeking' with its massive search dominance, masters 'Screening' with millions of reviews and detailed product info, perfects 'Selecting' with one-click purchasing, and fuels 'Sharing' with its review ecosystem. Direct-to-consumer brands like Glossier or Allbirds are also prime examples; they build communities that supercharge the 'Sharing' phase, which in turn drives the entire flywheel for new customers.
Discover more from Shaynly
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.